Sonata in A

this is my arrangements of mozarts sonata in A, which do you think is better?:) They are not balanced, I am still working on them.

Sonata2. VOTE

Sonata3. Vote

Sonata2.MUS

Sonata3.MUS

Here they are.:)

Sonata2.pdf

Sonata3.pdf

This doesn't belong in the vocal section.

1) There is no text to be set

2) It is basically an orchestration of the same sonata, only you decided to call the instruments voices

3) The parts are unsingable

4) It displays no real arranging talent of any kind on your part

Add text, remove about half the parts (the ones which are unneccessary), and be more creative with your arrangements. As it is, this piece belongs in the "Workshop" area, and should never be displayed as a "choral piece"

This doesn't belong in the vocal section.

1) There is no text to be set

2) It is basically an orchestration of the same sonata, only you decided to call the instruments voices

3) The parts are unsingable

4) It displays no real arranging talent of any kind on your part

Add text, remove about half the parts (the ones which are unneccessary), and be more creative with your arrangements. As it is, this piece belongs in the "Workshop" area, and should never be displayed as a "choral piece"

May you please show me what you mean?:)...as in on the score.

Uh.... do I really need to? The comments run through the entire piece. There's not really anything more to say. I'll comment more on range laterl.

Uh.... do I really need to? The comments run through the entire piece. There's not really anything more to say. I'll comment more on range laterl.

ok

I rewrote the chorus for you and cleaned it up:

Arrangement of Sonata in A (Mozart)

Arrangement of Sonata in A (Mozart).MID

I rewrote the chorus for you and cleaned it up:

Chorus

post a midi...I have 2006

If you wish, but the mp3 is a million times better even though they're both crappy. Too bad you can't get it, oh well.

This is Creationartis's mp3 of Sonata in A...he fixed it for moi.

http://esnips.com/doc/fec8f982-853e-...691ec53/Chorus

I uploaded all new files after correcting it a few times.

New mp3:

Arrangement of Sonata in A (Mozart)

The post with the new midi and score is ^ up there in my post.

sorry to be a spoil sport, but all the arrangements are dreadful.

they are full of voice-leading errors, range errors (since when can tenors sing a contra E?), and of course there are some liberties taken with the harmony that just don't fit.

I rewrote the chorus for you and cleaned it up:

Do you have a PDF version? I can't open .MUS files as I don't have Finale.

Do you have a PDF version? I can't open .MUS files as I don't have Finale.

I posted some.

sorry to be a spoil sport, but all the arrangements are dreadful.

they are full of voice-leading errors, range errors (since when can tenors sing a contra E?), and of course there are some liberties taken with the harmony that just don't fit.

Maybe I did not post it here, I Suck at writing for vocals.

sorry to be a spoil sport, but all the arrangements are dreadful.

they are full of voice-leading errors, range errors (since when can tenors sing a contra E?), and of course there are some liberties taken with the harmony that just don't fit.

Whatever, I like the way it sounds :wacko: We'll get to voice-leading when we get to voice-leading. :laugh:

Maybe I did not post it here, I Suck at writing for vocals.

So when you posteda a choral arrangement as a piece on the choral/vocal section, what was your point? :angry:

Here's the PDF to a newer version. The voices used in Finale are a little sloppy, but it's still the same score.

Mozart Sonata Vocal Arrangement.pdf

This is the wierdest thread...:happy:

Have you not read Masturbation? :huh:

It's far too low. . . . isn't it? It sounds unsingable.

Have you not read Masturbation? :huh:

:huh:

It's far too low. . . . isn't it? It sounds unsingable.

I know. It was just for fun.:huh:

I think he meant my PDF.

:huh:

It all makes sense when you look at it in context.