January 18, 20251 yr Hi everyone, I’m new here! I’ve seen a few other pieces of music shared here, and it seems like the perfect place for me to join in. I’m a French student, and I’ve spent 12 years studying piano at a conservatory. Recently, I’ve started composing, and I feel confident enough about what I’ve created to share it with you. Right now, I don’t have anyone around for active listening, so I have no idea how to assess the quality of my compositions. I’d really appreciate honest feedback (whether it’s theoretical or just based on your feelings) to understand where I stand and how I can improve. I hope you will feel as much emotion listening to it as I did composing it 😀 Thank you in advance for your time and your insights!
January 18, 20251 yr I think it's a well-written, idiomatic little piece for the piano, moving and effective. Perhaps it has little development or, rather, relies on a theme repeated quite a few times. But given the length of the piece, it does not become tiresome.
January 19, 20251 yr Author Thank you for the feedback. I had some non-musicians listen to my compositions, and they mentioned that they had trouble understanding what was going on like there were too many elements and too many ideas. So, I tried to simplify both the structure and the harmony. However, I may have gone too far. It’s hard to find the right balance
(1).thumb.jpeg.ee353fd3820ac08cb85c75aad438126d.jpeg)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.