Jump to content

Neo-baroque suite


Recommended Posts

Very nice.. I marvel at what you accomplish with grace, and not an over abundance of notes. Thanx for the chords too. it helps me to understand what is happening.

I start a composition with blocked piano chords, in my DAW, which is removed/muted after a few tracks.. As I add individual parts, I notice I change the original chords.  The chords become more complex, and sometimes mutate into a related, but different chord.. 

Thanx

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cool.
The second movement's time signature should probably just be 3 instead of 3/4 for all the hemiolas you write in, since the notation of changing them wasn't really a thing yet.
Some of your chords seem to be working under functional harmony rather than empirical harmony, which is fine, just something to note. It's a little bit inconsistent sometimes with your NC markings.
Nice stuff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

Nice!  I didn't know you composed dances as well!  It's cool to hear a more modern approach to these old dances.  Even having composed quite a few of these myself - I am no expert as this is quite a wide field of study.  Given that - I do have some points that you are free to ignore if you disagree with of course.  I think the Courante as you have it ventures a bit too frequently into a 6/8 hemiola which makes it momentarily sound like it's a Gigue.  That part of it just seemed out of character for a Courante.  Also your Allemande to me sounded more like a Gavotte in tempo and general approach.  As I understand it Allemande's are supposed to be a bit slower and have an anacursis of between 2 or 3 sixteenth-notes (although that's free to interpretation - the important thing to note is that in an Allemande sixteenth notes are expected to pass slowly enough that it would still sound dance-like).  I don't know if I've ever heard a Musette as an independent dance like this - I thought it would usually appear as a section of another dance like the trio is a section of a minuet.  When I search for Musette I get a Wikipedia article that says that Schoenberg composed a suite in which one of the movements was an independent Musette.  I wrote a Musette once as part of my Gigue in Eb and the way I understood it there was that it was a contrasting section of a Gigue that was supposed to imitate the drone of bagpipes.  I thought your Sarabande and Gigue were quite appropriate in manner and tempo.  Nice job overall!  I always enjoy listening to these quirky little specimens.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, PaperComposer said:

Nice!  I didn't know you composed dances as well!  It's cool to hear a more modern approach to these old dances.  Even having composed quite a few of these myself - I am no expert as this is quite a wide field of study.  Given that - I do have some points that you are free to ignore if you disagree with of course.  I think the Courante as you have it ventures a bit too frequently into a 6/8 hemiola which makes it momentarily sound like it's a Gigue.  That part of it just seemed out of character for a Courante.  Also your Allemande to me sounded more like a Gavotte in tempo and general approach.  As I understand it Allemande's are supposed to be a bit slower and have an anacursis of between 2 or 3 sixteenth-notes (although that's free to interpretation - the important thing to note is that in an Allemande sixteenth notes are expected to pass slowly enough that it would still sound dance-like).  I don't know if I've ever heard a Musette as an independent dance like this - I thought it would usually appear as a section of another dance like the trio is a section of a minuet.  When I search for Musette I get a Wikipedia article that says that Schoenberg composed a suite in which one of the movements was an independent Musette.  I wrote a Musette once as part of my Gigue in Eb and the way I understood it there was that it was a contrasting section of a Gigue that was supposed to imitate the drone of bagpipes.  I thought your Sarabande and Gigue were quite appropriate in manner and tempo.  Nice job overall!  I always enjoy listening to these quirky little specimens.

 

Hi.

Probably it is all as you say, I can't remember.... I wanted to study this baroque forms and I read from many sources. The information you get is different and didn't find absolute terms. I tried to follow the rhythms and tempi supposed to use, but al last, I always do what I want at the moment of writing. I don't care much about how to call every piece of the suite, perhaps I had to name them as 1, 2, 3, etc... Because in "contemporary thinking" you take the essence or just a tangent feature of a form and from that point, you develop a different type music.

If not, take a look at Schönberg's Mussete, from Op. 25.

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...